• Login
    • Join
  • FOLLOW:
  • Subscribe Free
    • Magazine
    • eNewsletter
    Checkout
    • Magazine
    • News
    • Exclusives
    • Nutraceuticals
    • Markets
    • Health
    • Jobs
    • Events
    • Buyers' Guide
    • Showcases
    • More
  • Magazine
  • News
  • Exclusives
  • Nutraceuticals
  • Markets
  • Health
  • Jobs
  • Events
  • Buyers' Guide
  • Showcases
  • Current & Past Issues
    Features
    Columns
    Editorials
    Digital Edition
    Subscribe Now
    Advertise Now
    eNewsletter
    Editorial Guidelines
    Top Features
    Contract Manufacturing: Trials & Tribulations of Today’s Supply Chains

    Analytical Testing in Nutraceuticals: Methods and Mindsets to Uphold Quality

    Nutrition and Flavor: Formulating for Modern Product Preferences

    What Do Consumers Know About the Gut Microbiome?

    How Will the European Green Deal Impact Dietary Supplements?
    Breaking News
    Certifications, Approvals and Patents
    Exclusives
    Industry & Market News
    People
    Products
    Regulatory
    Research
    Supplier News
    Supplier Insights
    Live From Shows
    Top News
    3i Solutions Announces New Leadership Positions

    INS Nutra Opens Gummy Manufacturing Facility

    Vital Nutrients Launches First Vegan Omega Supplement with SPMs

    Earth Mama Organics Achieves 'Plastic Neutral' Certification

    TopGum Gummies Receives USDA Organic Certification
    Exclusives
    Blogs & Guest Articles
    Health E-Insights
    Area Code 420
    eBook
    Antioxidants
    Dairy-Based Ingredients
    Enzymes
    Fatty Acids
    Fiber & Carbohydrates
    Green Foods
    Herbs & Botanicals
    Marine Nutraceuticals
    Minerals
    Omega 3s
    Probiotics & Prebiotics
    Proteins, Peptides, Amino Acids
    Sweeteners
    Vitamins

    Vital Nutrients Launches First Vegan Omega Supplement with SPMs

    Bill Chioffi Joins Nammex as Chief Strategy and Innovation Officer

    FDA Issues ‘No Questions’ Letter for Chiber Mushroom Fiber Preservative

    VITAL Ancillary Study Finds No Link Between Vitamin D and Bone Fracture Risk

    FDA Issues Final Guidance on NAC Supplements
    Consumer Trends
    Contract Manufacturing
    Cosmeceuticals / Nutricosmetics
    Delivery & Dosage Technologies
    Dietary Supplements
    Flavors & Colors
    Functional Foods & Beverages
    Healthcare Trends
    Medical Nutrition
    Mergers & Acquisitions
    Natural/Organic
    Nutrition Bars
    Packaging
    Pet Nutraceuticals
    Quality & Safety
    Regulations
    Research
    Testing
    World Markets

    3i Solutions Announces New Leadership Positions

    INS Nutra Opens Gummy Manufacturing Facility

    Vital Nutrients Launches First Vegan Omega Supplement with SPMs

    Earth Mama Organics Achieves 'Plastic Neutral' Certification

    TopGum Gummies Receives USDA Organic Certification
    Bone & Joint Health
    Cancer Risk
    Cardiovascular Health
    Cognitive Function
    Diabetes & Blood Sugar Management
    Digestive Health
    Energy
    Eye Health
    Healthy Aging
    Immune Function
    Infant & Children's Health
    Inflammation
    Men's Health
    Mood Health & Sleep
    Oral Health
    Sexual & Reproductive Health
    Skin Health
    Sports Nutrition
    Weight Management/Weight Loss
    Women's Health

    Vital Nutrients Launches First Vegan Omega Supplement with SPMs

    VITAL Ancillary Study Finds No Link Between Vitamin D and Bone Fracture Risk

    Krill Oil Study Provides Evidence of Osteoarthritis Benefits

    Immunobiotic Heat-Killed Bacteria Linked to Skin Benefits

    Folic Acid Appears Beneficial in Type 2 Diabetes
    Industry Events
    Live From Show Events
    Webinars
    All Companies
    Categories
    Trade Associations
    Company Capabilities
    International Buyers Guide Companies
    PhytoGaia Inc

    Botanic Healthcare LLC

    Bioenergy Life Science, Inc. (BLS)

    Aiya America, Inc. (Aiya Matcha)

    Atlantia Clinical Trials
    Companies
    Product Releases
    News Releases
    Literature / Brochures
    White Papers
    Jobs
    VIdeos
    Services
    Add New Company
    International Buyers Guide Companies
    PhytoGaia Inc

    Botanic Healthcare LLC

    Bioenergy Life Science, Inc. (BLS)

    Aiya America, Inc. (Aiya Matcha)

    Atlantia Clinical Trials
    • Magazine
      • Current / Back Issue
      • Features
      • Editorial
      • Columns
      • Digital Edition
      • eNewsletter Archive
      • Editorial Guidelines
      • Subscribe Now
      • Advertise Now
    • Breaking News
    • Buyers' Guide
      • All Companies
      • Categories
      • Trade Associations
      • Company Capabilities
    • Nutraceuticals
      • Antioxidants
      • Dairy-Based Ingredients
      • Enzymes
      • Fatty Acids
      • Fiber & Carbohydrates
      • Green Foods
      • Herbs & Botanicals
      • Marine Nutraceuticals
      • Minerals
      • Omega 3s
      • Probiotics & Prebiotics
      • Proteins, Peptides, Amino Acids
      • Sweeteners
      • Vitamins
    • Markets
      • Consumer Trends
      • Contract Manufacturing
      • Cosmeceuticals / Nutricosmetics
      • Delivery & Dosage Technologies
      • Dietary Supplements
      • Flavors & Colors
      • Functional Foods & Beverages
      • Healthcare Trends
      • Medical Nutrition
      • Mergers & Acquisitions
      • Natural/Organic
      • Nutrition Bars
      • Packaging
      • Pet Nutraceuticals
      • Quality & Safety
      • Regulations
      • Research
      • Testing
      • World Markets
    • Health
      • Bone & Joint Health
      • Cancer Risk
      • Cardiovascular Health
      • Cognitive Function
      • Diabetes & Blood Sugar Management
      • Digestive Health
      • Energy
      • Eye Health
      • Healthy Aging
      • Immune Function
      • Infant & Children's Health
      • Inflammation
      • Men's Health
      • Mood Health & Sleep
      • Oral Health
      • Sexual & Reproductive Health
      • Skin Health
      • Sports Nutrition
      • Weight Management/Weight Loss
      • Women's Health
    • Online Exclusives
    • Webinars
    • Slideshows
    • Blogs & Guest Articles
    • Health E-Insights
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • Infographics
    • eBook
    • Whitepapers
    • Research
      • TrendSense
      • Monograph Center
      • White Papers
      • Research News
    • Jobs
    • Events
      • Industry Events
      • Live From Show Events
      • Webinars
    • Supplier Showcases
      • Companies
      • Product Releases
      • News Releases
      • Literature / Brochures
      • White Papers
      • Jobs
      • VIdeos
      • Services
    • About Us
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
      • Advertise With Us
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Use
    Columns

    Patent Litigation By Non-Practicing Entities Rising

    Over the past year, several new NPEs have emerged to file more than 100 patent infringement lawsuits against dietary supplement companies.

    Related CONTENT
    • Understanding FTC Standards for Claims Substantiation
    • ABC Mourns the Passing of Fredi Kronenberg
    • Political Disruption Presents Opportunity for Industry
    • Understanding GMO Labeling Legislation
    • The Regulatory Drumbeat Continues to Echo
    Todd Harrison, Stefan Kirchanski, PhD, Daniel Silverman & Tamany Vinson Bentz, Venable06.03.13
    In 2012, non-practicing entities (NPEs) filed the majority of the patent infringement lawsuits in the U.S. RPX Corporation, which acquires patents on behalf of its members and then licenses them to all members, reported that 62% of all patent litigation—amounting to 2,921 of the 4,701 suits in 2012—were filed by NPEs. Once perceived as limited to technology industries, NPEs have become prevalent across a wide span of non-technology based industries, including the dietary supplement industry. Over the past year, for example, several new NPEs, all represented by the same counsel, have emerged and filed more than 100 patent infringement lawsuits against supplement companies.

    Tawnsaura: In August 2012, The Tawnsaura Group began filing suits in the Central District of California, alleging infringement of two patents concerning uses for L-citrulline. These filings have continued into April 2013, bringing the total number of companies sued to 87.

    The two patents at issue were filed by an individual, Dr. William Waugh. Dr. Waugh passed away in the summer of 2012, and in August his estate sold the patents to Tawnsaura, an entity with no products on the market, which was formed solely to assert the patents for commercial gain. Five days after Tawnsaura acquired the patents, it began filing infringement suits.

    The number of cases filed by Tawnsaura attracted the attention of the court, which assigned them all to a single judge and coordinated them for pretrial purposes. The court then immediately stayed the cases and ordered Tawnsaura to amend its complaints to make specific allegations as to each defendant and each accused product. The court ordered that Tawnsaura could not rely on the typical “upon information and belief” language used by many NPEs to circumvent the testing that would be required to allege infringement of patent claims and particularly claims directed at supplements. Once the complaints were amended, the court, on its own initiative, dismissed certain claims and narrowed the scope of available damages. This level of involvement by the court in the early stages of a case is rare, and may be an indication that the court was concerned by the large number of suits filed.

    Thermolife: In October 2012, the same counsel who represents Tawnsaura filed a patent infringement suit in the Central District of California on behalf of Thermolife International against 19 supplement manufacturers and distributors. Thermolife is an uncommon NPE because it has a limited number of sports nutrition products for sale on its website. Nevertheless, it has taken on the NPE business model by purchasing the rights to allegedly broad based patents and then leveraging them for licensing and royalty payments by filing patent infringement lawsuits across the entire supplement industry.

    This suit involves a patent for testosterone booster D-Aspartic Acid. As originally filed, Thermolife lumped all of the 19 defendants together in one lawsuit. Filing one case against unrelated defendants, however, is in violation of the new patent statute, commonly referred to as the America Invents Act (35 U.S.C. § 299(b)). The statute forces NPEs to break unrelated defendants out in multiple cases and was intended to curb NPE cases. It has not had a significant effect, however. On Feb. 14, the court dismissed all of Thermolife’s claims except those against the first named defendant and ordered that Thermolife re-file separate suits. On Feb. 21, Thermolife re-filed separate lawsuits against the originally named companies and added some new defendants. Like in the Tawnsaura suits, these suits have been consolidated before one judge.

    Thermolife II: Beginning in March 2013, Thermolife began filing a second round of cases against various supplement companies in the Southern District of California. These claims concern a family of patents directed primarily to the use of L-arginine to increase nitric oxide production. In February, the patents were licensed by Thermolife from Stanford University, and the suits began a month later. Thus far, 25 suits have been filed.

    Harcol: Also in March 2013, the same attorneys who filed the Tawnsaura and Thermolife actions began filing patent infringement suits on behalf of Harcol Research in the Eastern District of Texas. Thus far, 10 of these suits have been filed by Harcol, which is a true NPE with no known products on the market. Its claims are based on a patent directed to beverages “containing alpha-ketoglutaric acid.”

    NPE-filed suits require the companies sued to incur significant expenses, even in cases involving weak patents in which the patents are likely invalid and/or there is no infringement. A typical budget for a patent case through trial is more than $1 million. Knowing this, it is not uncommon for initial settlement demands from an NPE to be excessive compared to sales of a product. Thus, a defendant’s only choice, at least initially, is to fight the litigation or overpay to settle the claims.

    Defense Against NPEs
    There are ways defendants seek to defend against meritless claims and efficiently manage the cost of litigation. In some cases, defendants hire joint or shared counsel and then divide the fees across the jointly represented companies. This arrangement results in drastically lower expenses and fees for any one defendant and a cohesive defense strategy, both of which favor defendants in a litigation.

    Even if defendants are not jointly represented they nonetheless often form joint defense groups. The defendants in a joint defense group are not jointly represented by one counsel or firm; rather, the various attorneys coordinate activities and work together to share the burden of litigation and costs. As is typical with group efforts, there are often freeloaders who reap the benefits of the joint strategy without incurring any expense. To offset this effect, some large joint defense groups require parties to buy into the group with an upfront payment. Other joint defense groups have required members to buy into particular events. For instance, if parties want to join in a motion to dismiss, then every party who wants to join in the motion must pay its fair share.

    Joint representation and joint defense groups help offset the expense of litigation, but do little to prevent the larger problem: NPE litigation generally. For years, a variety of industries have grappled with how to protect against NPE litigation. Companies in certain industries have banded together to fund companies that purchase and license patents, thereby creating competition for NPEs in the market for patents. Others have taken an aggressive approach to NPE litigation either by refusing to settle any cases with NPEs or by asserting strong counterclaims against NPEs. Other aggressive approaches include filing early motions to dismiss and/or seeking sanctions under Rule 11 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure on grounds plaintiff’s counsel failed to conduct proper due diligence before filing suits involving clearly invalid patents.

    While many debate the validity of patent infringement claims brought by NPEs because NPEs have no products on the market, it is unlikely that the industry will see a resolution to the issue in the near future. Unfortunately, it is more likely that the industry will continue to see a rise in NPE litigation and related expenses, as is the case in many other industries across the country.  

    __________________________________________________________________________________________________________

    Todd Harrison is partner with Venable, which is located in Washington, D.C. He advises food and drug companies on a variety of FDA and FTC matters, with an emphasis on dietary supplement, functional food, biotech, legislative, adulteration, labeling and advertising issues. He can be reached at 575 7th St. NW, Washington, D.C. 20004, Tel: 202-344-4724; E-mail: taharrison@venable.com.
    Related Searches
    • Adulteration
    • Dietary Supplement
    • Sports Nutrition
    • Testing
    Related Knowledge Center
    • Dietary Supplements
    • Regulations
    • Sports Nutrition
    Suggested For You
    Understanding FTC Standards for Claims Substantiation Understanding FTC Standards for Claims Substantiation
    ABC Mourns the Passing of Fredi Kronenberg ABC Mourns the Passing of Fredi Kronenberg
    Political Disruption Presents  Opportunity for Industry Political Disruption Presents Opportunity for Industry
    Understanding GMO Labeling Legislation Understanding GMO Labeling Legislation
    The Regulatory Drumbeat Continues to Echo The Regulatory Drumbeat Continues to Echo
    Sabinsa Honored With Two Pharmexcil Awards Sabinsa Honored With Two Pharmexcil Awards
    NCN Webinar to Address Draft Guidance for New Dietary Ingredient Notifications
 NCN Webinar to Address Draft Guidance for New Dietary Ingredient Notifications

    Can More Fiber Restore Microbiome Diversity? Can More Fiber Restore Microbiome Diversity?
    PureCircle Awarded Patent for Reb M in Beverages PureCircle Awarded Patent for Reb M in Beverages
    Sabinsa Honored With Two New Pharmexcil Awards Sabinsa Honored With Two New Pharmexcil Awards
    Added Sugars Consumed by U.S. Adults Up 30% in Three Decades Added Sugars Consumed by U.S. Adults Up 30% in Three Decades
    Best Practices For Developing Patent Strategies Best Practices For Developing Patent Strategies
    WELL Study to Examine Impacts of Diet & Lifestyle on Healthy Aging WELL Study to Examine Impacts of Diet & Lifestyle on Healthy Aging
    Magnesium Reverses Alzheimer’s Symptoms in Mice Magnesium Reverses Alzheimer’s Symptoms in Mice
    Healthcare Practitioner Marketing: Protecting Intellectual Property: Part II Healthcare Practitioner Marketing: Protecting Intellectual Property: Part II

    Related Columns

    • Dietary Supplements | Regulations | Research
      Understanding FTC Standards for Claims Substantiation

      Understanding FTC Standards for Claims Substantiation

      Randomized clinical trials aren’t the only source of competent and reliable scientific evidence.
      By Todd Harrison, Venable 06.02.17

    • Breaking News | People News

      ABC Mourns the Passing of Fredi Kronenberg

      Founding editor of the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, she served on the ABC Board of Trustees since 1999.
      04.25.17

    • Dietary Supplements | Healthcare Trends | Quality & Safety | Regulations
      Political Disruption Presents  Opportunity for Industry

      Political Disruption Presents Opportunity for Industry

      How can the regulatory framework be improved in order to benefit business and consumers?
      Todd Harrison, Venable 04.03.17


    • Natural/Organic | Packaging | Quality & Safety | Regulations | Testing
      Understanding GMO Labeling Legislation

      Understanding GMO Labeling Legislation

      Here’s a primer on the U.S. law that mandates a national standard for disclosing bioengineered foods.
      Todd Harrison & Michelle Jackson, Venable 01.04.17

    • Dietary Supplements | Quality & Safety | Regulations | Testing
      The Regulatory Drumbeat Continues to Echo

      The Regulatory Drumbeat Continues to Echo

      FDA’s latest actions exemplify how it views the dietary supplement industry.
      Todd Harrison, Venable 11.01.16

    Loading, Please Wait..
    Trending
    • First Day Life Shuts Down Children's Behavioral, Cognitive Health Claims Following Challenge
    • Study Examines Vitamin K2 Content In Cheese
    • Pycnogenol Evidenced To Have Skin Benefits In Dermatology Study
    Breaking News
    • 3i Solutions Announces New Leadership Positions
    • INS Nutra Opens Gummy Manufacturing Facility
    • Vital Nutrients Launches First Vegan Omega Supplement with SPMs
    • Earth Mama Organics Achieves 'Plastic Neutral' Certification
    • TopGum Gummies Receives USDA Organic Certification
    View Breaking News >
    CURRENT ISSUE

    July/August 2022

    • A Growing Herbal Products Market Still Faces Formidable Threats, Challenges
    • Analytical Testing in Nutraceuticals: Methods and Mindsets to Uphold Quality
    • Nutrition and Flavor: Formulating for Modern Product Preferences
    • Contract Manufacturing: Trials & Tribulations of Today’s Supply Chains
    • How Will the European Green Deal Impact Dietary Supplements?
    • What Do Consumers Know About the Gut Microbiome?
    • View More >

    Cookies help us to provide you with an excellent service. By using our website, you declare yourself in agreement with our use of cookies.
    You can obtain detailed information about the use of cookies on our website by clicking on "More information”.

    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms And Conditions
    • Contact Us

    follow us

    Subscribe
    Nutraceuticals World

    Latest Breaking News From Nutraceuticals World

    3i Solutions Announces New Leadership Positions
    INS Nutra Opens Gummy Manufacturing Facility
    Vital Nutrients Launches First Vegan Omega Supplement with SPMs
    Coatings World

    Latest Breaking News From Coatings World

    ICP Building Solutions Group Names Sami Rahman New Chief Commercial Officer
    Tnemec Introduces Series 21 Epoxoline
    Make UK Defence Collaborates with HMG Paints
    Medical Product Outsourcing

    Latest Breaking News From Medical Product Outsourcing

    MPO's Most-Read Stories This Week—Aug. 6
    Ampersand Capital Partners Invests in Sterling Medical Devices
    ICG Acquires Seaway Plastics Engineering
    Contract Pharma

    Latest Breaking News From Contract Pharma

    Datwyler to Double Capacity at Production Ops in Pune
    Thorne HealthTech, AstraZeneca Entend AI Discovery Alliance
    Aptar Pharma Acquires Worldwide Rights to Pharmaxis’ Orbital Inhaler
    Beauty Packaging

    Latest Breaking News From Beauty Packaging

    Alicia Keys Introduces Keys Soulcare’s First SPF Skincare Offering
    Kylie Gets Backlash for Makeup Lab Photo Shoot
    Redken Celebrates Hair Gloss Day
    Happi

    Latest Breaking News From Happi

    CEO Named at Ourself, Ulta Beauty’s Digital Investment Fund, Spate Insight
    UK Society of Cosmetic Scientists Launches New Introduction to Cosmetic Science
    Metallic Eyeshadow, Body Glitter and Glow Blush Top Latest Beauty Searches: Spate
    Ink World

    Latest Breaking News From Ink World

    Weekly Recap: Zeller+Gmelin, Epple Druckfarben Lead This Week’s News Stories
    A-Flex Label Adds Epson SurePress UV Digital Label Press
    Ball Announces 2Q 2022 Results
    Label & Narrow Web

    Latest Breaking News From Label & Narrow Web

    FLAG to hold roundtable event at Labelexpo Americas
    Premier Packaging expands, Resource Label promotes culture and more
    Labelink acquires Taylor Label and The Label Factory
    Nonwovens Industry

    Latest Breaking News From Nonwovens Industry

    Weekly Recap: A New Day for Hygiene, Glatfelter Reports Q2 Results & More
    Dyper Achieves B Corp Certification
    Edgewell’s Sales Grow
    Orthopedic Design & Technology

    Latest Breaking News From Orthopedic Design & Technology

    ODT's Most-Read Stories This Week—Aug. 6
    Spineology Releases Endoscopic, Single-Tubular Retractor Fusion System
    GreenBone Signs Distribution Agreement for its Regenerative Scaffold
    Printed Electronics Now

    Latest Breaking News From Printed Electronics Now

    Weekly Recap: STMicroelectronics, NextFlex and onsemi Top This Week’s Stories
    Zebra Technologies Reports 2Q 2022 Results
    InnovationLab Demonstrates New PCB Production Method Based on Additive Manufacturing

    Copyright © 2022 Rodman Media. All rights reserved. Use of this constitutes acceptance of our privacy policy The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Rodman Media.

    AD BLOCKER DETECTED

    Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
    Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.


    FREE SUBSCRIPTION Already a subscriber? Login