• Login
    • Join
  • FOLLOW:
  • Subscribe Free
    • Magazine
    • eNewsletter
    Checkout
    • Magazine
    • News
    • Exclusives
    • Nutraceuticals
    • Markets
    • Health
    • Jobs
    • Events
    • Buyers' Guide
    • Showcases
    • More
  • Magazine
  • News
  • Exclusives
  • Nutraceuticals
  • Markets
  • Health
  • Jobs
  • Events
  • Buyers' Guide
  • Showcases
  • Current & Past Issues
    Features
    Columns
    Editorials
    Digital Edition
    Subscribe Now
    Advertise Now
    eNewsletter
    Editorial Guidelines
    Top Features
    Health Products Association - China Executive Director Reflects on Market Dynamics, Challenges

    Blood Sugar Management: Personalized Testing Drives Home The Need for Early Intervention

    New and Evolving Formulation Options Must Be Mindful of Blood Sugar Maintenance

    Tapping Functional Beverages to Meet Modern Wellness Needs

    Adaptogens: Where Ancient Remedies Meet Modern Wellness Products
    Breaking News
    Certifications, Approvals and Patents
    Exclusives
    Industry & Market News
    People
    Products
    Regulatory
    Research
    Supplier News
    Supplier Insights
    Live From Shows
    Top News
    CoQ10 and Royal Jelly Supplementation May Improve High Intensity Exercise

    Shiitake Mushroom Extract Appears Helpful in HPV Infections

    Fi & Hi Europe Returns with Over 20,000 Global Attendees Expected

    United Plant Savers Launches First Film Festival

    Azelis Opens Food and Nutrition Lab in Cairo, Egypt
    Exclusives
    Blogs & Guest Articles
    Health E-Insights
    Area Code 420
    eBook
    Antioxidants
    Dairy-Based Ingredients
    Enzymes
    Fatty Acids
    Fiber & Carbohydrates
    Green Foods
    Herbs & Botanicals
    Marine Nutraceuticals
    Minerals
    Omega 3s
    Probiotics & Prebiotics
    Proteins, Peptides, Amino Acids
    Sweeteners
    Vitamins

    CoQ10 and Royal Jelly Supplementation May Improve High Intensity Exercise

    Shiitake Mushroom Extract Appears Helpful in HPV Infections

    United Plant Savers Launches First Film Festival

    Roquette Launches Nutralys Rice Protein

    Upcycled Coffeeberry® Cascara Offers Versatility in Functional Beverage Development
    Consumer Trends
    Contract Manufacturing
    Cosmeceuticals / Nutricosmetics
    Delivery & Dosage Technologies
    Dietary Supplements
    Flavors & Colors
    Functional Foods & Beverages
    Healthcare Trends
    Medical Nutrition
    Mergers & Acquisitions
    Natural/Organic
    Nutrition Bars
    Packaging
    Pet Nutraceuticals
    Quality & Safety
    Regulations
    Research
    Testing
    World Markets

    CoQ10 and Royal Jelly Supplementation May Improve High Intensity Exercise

    Shiitake Mushroom Extract Appears Helpful in HPV Infections

    Fi & Hi Europe Returns with Over 20,000 Global Attendees Expected

    Azelis Opens Food and Nutrition Lab in Cairo, Egypt

    Florida Food Products Acquires Javo
    Bone & Joint Health
    Cancer Risk
    Cardiovascular Health
    Cognitive Function
    Diabetes & Blood Sugar Management
    Digestive Health
    Energy
    Eye Health
    Healthy Aging
    Immune Function
    Infant & Children's Health
    Inflammation
    Men's Health
    Mood Health & Sleep
    Oral Health
    Sexual & Reproductive Health
    Skin Health
    Sports Nutrition
    Weight Management/Weight Loss
    Women's Health

    CoQ10 and Royal Jelly Supplementation May Improve High Intensity Exercise

    Shiitake Mushroom Extract Appears Helpful in HPV Infections

    Upcycled Coffeeberry® Cascara Offers Versatility in Functional Beverage Development

    Botanical Gum for Kids Aims to Curb Sugar Cravings

    Combination of Collagen and Boswellia Serrata Shown to Reduce Joint Discomfort
    Industry Events
    Live From Show Events
    Webinars
    All Companies
    Categories
    Trade Associations
    Company Capabilities
    International Buyers Guide Companies
    Nutrition21, LLC

    KLK OLEO

    Ecuadorian Rainforest

    Bioactive Resources

    Gencor
    Companies
    Product Releases
    News Releases
    Literature / Brochures
    White Papers
    Jobs
    VIdeos
    Services
    Add New Company
    International Buyers Guide Companies
    Nutrition21, LLC

    KLK OLEO

    Ecuadorian Rainforest

    Bioactive Resources

    Gencor
    • Magazine
      • Current / Back Issue
      • Features
      • Editorial
      • Columns
      • Digital Edition
      • eNewsletter Archive
      • Editorial Guidelines
      • Subscribe Now
      • Advertise Now
    • Breaking News
    • Buyers' Guide
      • All Companies
      • Categories
      • Trade Associations
      • Company Capabilities
    • Nutraceuticals
      • Antioxidants
      • Dairy-Based Ingredients
      • Enzymes
      • Fatty Acids
      • Fiber & Carbohydrates
      • Green Foods
      • Herbs & Botanicals
      • Marine Nutraceuticals
      • Minerals
      • Omega 3s
      • Probiotics & Prebiotics
      • Proteins, Peptides, Amino Acids
      • Sweeteners
      • Vitamins
    • Markets
      • Consumer Trends
      • Contract Manufacturing
      • Cosmeceuticals / Nutricosmetics
      • Delivery & Dosage Technologies
      • Dietary Supplements
      • Flavors & Colors
      • Functional Foods & Beverages
      • Healthcare Trends
      • Medical Nutrition
      • Mergers & Acquisitions
      • Natural/Organic
      • Nutrition Bars
      • Packaging
      • Pet Nutraceuticals
      • Quality & Safety
      • Regulations
      • Research
      • Testing
      • World Markets
    • Health
      • Bone & Joint Health
      • Cancer Risk
      • Cardiovascular Health
      • Cognitive Function
      • Diabetes & Blood Sugar Management
      • Digestive Health
      • Energy
      • Eye Health
      • Healthy Aging
      • Immune Function
      • Infant & Children's Health
      • Inflammation
      • Men's Health
      • Mood Health & Sleep
      • Oral Health
      • Sexual & Reproductive Health
      • Skin Health
      • Sports Nutrition
      • Weight Management/Weight Loss
      • Women's Health
    • Online Exclusives
    • Webinars
    • Slideshows
    • Blogs & Guest Articles
    • Health E-Insights
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • Infographics
    • eBook
    • Whitepapers
    • Research
      • TrendSense
      • Monograph Center
      • White Papers
      • Research News
    • Jobs
    • Events
      • Industry Events
      • Live From Show Events
      • Webinars
    • Supplier Showcases
      • Companies
      • Product Releases
      • News Releases
      • Literature / Brochures
      • White Papers
      • Jobs
      • VIdeos
      • Services
    • About Us
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
      • Advertise With Us
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Use
    Expert's Opinion

    U.S. Supreme Court Hears Arguments in Pom Wonderful vs. Coca-Cola Case

    Who should decide whether a food label is deceptive?

    Related CONTENT
    • Understanding FTC Standards for Claims Substantiation
    • Transforming Health with Nature’s Sunshine
    • TREHA Trehalose Available As ‘Natural Flavor’
    • ConsumerLab.com Tests Popular Vitamin D Supplements
    • Gottlieb Confirmed to Lead FDA
    Claudia Vetesi & Lisa Wongchenko, Morrison & Foerster05.12.14
    Does compliance with FDA’s food labeling regulations shield a company from false advertising claims challenging those labels? That was the key question in a much-anticipated oral argument before the U.S. Supreme Court last month involving Pom Wonderful’s claims against competitor beverage company Coca-Cola. [Pom Wonderful LLC v. Coca-Cola Co., 134 S. Ct. 895 (2014).]  The food industry is watching closely as the Supreme Court grapples with who should be tasked with protecting consumers from misleading food labels.    
     
    Coca-Cola’s ‘Pomegranate Blueberry Flavored Blend of 5 Juices’
    At issue is the labeling of Coca-Cola’s “Pomegranate Blueberry Flavored Blend of 5 Juices,” which is 99% apple and grape juice. Pom, a seller of pomegranate juice, sued Coca-Cola in 2007, alleging that the juice’s name and other labeling features were misleading under the federal Lanham Act—a statute that allows suit based on the false or misleading description of goods (15 U.S.C. § 1125(a))—because apple and grape juice are the primary ingredients. The company also brought state claims, which are not part of the appeal. Coca-Cola asserted that its label complies with the federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FDCA) and, as such, Pom’s claims are barred.
     
    Lower Court Rulings: FDCA Precludes Pom’s Lanham Act Claim
    The district court agreed with Coca-Cola, finding that Pom’s Lanham Act claim was barred by the FDCA’s food and beverage labeling regulations. In particular, FDA regulations explicitly permit a manufacturer to name a beverage using the name of a flavoring juice that is not predominant by volume, as Coca-Cola had apparently done [Pom Wonderful LLC v. Coca-Cola Co., No. CV 08-06237 SJO (JTLx), 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 65233, at *5-15 (C.D. Cal. Feb. 10, 2009)].
     
    The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals reached the same conclusion on the Lanham Act claim after analyzing the potential conflict between the two broad federal statutes. [Pom Wonderful LLC v. Coca-Cola Co., 679 F.3d 1170, 1175 (9th Cir. 2012).] While the Lanham Act “broadly prohibits false advertising,” the FDCA “comprehensively regulates food and beverage labeling.” Id. The Ninth Circuit ultimately found that the FDCA precluded the claims—because Congress entrusted to FDA the task of interpreting and enforcing the FDCA, the FDCA could operate to limit claims under the Lanham Act. Id. at 1175-76. Pom petitioned the Supreme Court for certiorari, and the Court agreed to hear the case. 
     
    Pom Tells Supreme Court FDA Provides a Floor, Not a Ceiling
    At oral argument before the Supreme Court, Pom argued that FDA is not the sole arbiter of consumer deception. FDA regulations merely provide a floor, not a ceiling. Because no explicit language in either statute limits the application of the Lanham Act in this case, Pom argued that the Court should only bar the Lanham Act claim if there is an irreconcilable conflict. Such a conflict might exist if FDA regulations specially required a company to use a certain label. But here FDA regulations simply set the baseline, and mere compliance with regulations does not determine whether the labeling is misleading. According to Pom, Coca-Cola could have complied with both statutes.    
     
    Coca-Cola Responds that FDA’s Regulations Are the Final Say on Deception
    Coca-Cola, in turn, focused on the express preemption provisions that bar state claims. It argued that if Pom’s Lanham Act claim had been brought under state law, it would have been expressly preempted under the Nutrition Labeling and Education Act of 1990 (NLEA). The NLEA has an express preemption provision that bars state claims to the extent they seek to impose requirements that are “not identical” to federal law. If the same claims would be barred when styled under state law, it is only logical that Congress intended to preempt the claims under federal law too (or believed it had already done so). Some of the Justices appeared to question this approach; if Congress intended to bar state and federal claims under the express preemption provision, why didn’t it say so? Since Lanham Act claims would apply to all 50 states, why should the same concerns about national uniformity of labeling apply?
     
    Coca-Cola offered an alternative rationale as well: where two federal statutes overlap, the specific trumps the general. Here, the FDCA specifically addressed what types of juice labeling would be misleading. FDA’s determinations should preclude the more general Lanham Act. Chief Justice Roberts still wondered, however, why a label that fully complies with FDA regulations could not also be misleading.
     
    United States’ Argument: FDCA Precludes Lanham Act Claims Only If the Labels Comply
    The U.S. government filed a brief as amicus curiae, and argued for a middle ground approach.  A Lanham Act claim should be barred, it argued, if the challenged labeling complies with FDA regulations. As such, the district court should initially determine whether the labels are compliant. If the label is specifically authorized, then the Lanham Act claim is precluded. But if FDA has simply failed to forbid it, then the Lanham Act claim is not barred. 
     
    Justice Kennedy wondered whether this approach would be hard to enforce. How would parties and courts determine whether FDA made a deliberate decision to exclude a requirement or simply failed to consider it? And to what extent does FDA consider consumer confusion in drafting its regulations? 
     
    The Court’s Underlying Concern: Who Protects Consumers from Deception?
    A consistent theme running through the Court’s questioning is: who should be the guardian of protection from consumer deception? Justices Ginsburg, Roberts and Kennedy acknowledged that FDA handles issues of health and safety, but were skeptical that its regulations thoroughly consider consumer confusion. Both the government and Coca-Cola repeatedly assured the Court that FDA does focus on consumer deception. Indeed, the “misbranding” provisions of the NLEA specifically aim to prevent deceptive labeling, and the juice labeling regulation at issue was passed after extensive rule-making proceedings over the course of 25 years. 
     
    Nonetheless, some of the Justices questioned the notion that FDA should be the body in charge of food labeling deception. Justice Ginsburg, for example, asked whether the Lanham Act and FDCA might be serving different purposes—the former addressing deceptive sales practices, and the latter dealing with nutritional information and health claims. Justice Kagan asked why the Lanham Act could not be a complement to FDA’s regulations, and Justice Kennedy pointed to FDA’s limited resources as a reason why the Lanham Act may be better suited to address consumer deception. Questioning why the two statutes are necessarily in conflict, Chief Justice Roberts noted that consumer confusion has nothing to do with “health.” A bright line distinction between the Acts seemed to be appealing to some of the Justices.
     
    Finding that the two statutes serve different purposes would allow the Court to avoid preclusion and give effect to both Acts. The statutes could remain on equal footing, and the Court would avoid having to fashion a workable preclusion rule. But perhaps looming even larger in the courtroom was the issue of the merits. Some of the Justices may have been resistant to deferring to FDA based on the Justices’ perceptions of the actual label. Justice Kennedy said that it is relevant for the Court to consider whether people are “cheated” in buying the product. While Coca-Cola maintained that its label is not misleading, Justice Kennedy replied, “Don’t make me feel bad because I thought that this was pomegranate juice.”
     
    Conclusion
    Pom, Coca-Cola, and the U.S. presented different arguments on when and how the FDCA could trump a Lanham Act claim. But the primary concern addressed at oral argument appeared to be, “Who?” Does FDA adequately consider consumer deception or should private parties be allowed to build off of the baseline regulations? Whatever it decides, the Court’s ruling will surely shape food labeling litigation to come. 
     
    Claudia Vetesi and Lisa Wongchenko are litigation associates in Morrison & Foerster’s Consumer Litigation and Class Action Practice Group. They are frequent contributors to Morrison & Foerster’s Private Surgeon General Class Action Defender blog and can be reached at cvetesi@mofo.com and lwongchenko@mofo.com.
    Related Searches
    • Regulation
    • Nutritional
    • Regulations
    • Health
    Related Knowledge Center
    • Regulations
    Suggested For You
    Understanding FTC Standards for Claims Substantiation Understanding FTC Standards for Claims Substantiation
    Transforming Health with Nature’s Sunshine Transforming Health with Nature’s Sunshine
    TREHA Trehalose Available As ‘Natural Flavor’ TREHA Trehalose Available As ‘Natural Flavor’
    ConsumerLab.com Tests Popular Vitamin D Supplements ConsumerLab.com Tests Popular Vitamin D Supplements
    Gottlieb Confirmed to Lead FDA Gottlieb Confirmed to Lead FDA
    Pet Nutrition: A Legal Rundown Pet Nutrition: A Legal Rundown
    Sen. McCaskill Investigates Supplements Claiming Benefits for Dementia and Alzheimer’s Sen. McCaskill Investigates Supplements Claiming Benefits for Dementia and Alzheimer’s
    Awareness of Health & Fitness Propels the Sports Category Awareness of Health & Fitness Propels the Sports Category
    POM Wonderful: The Ripple Effect               POM Wonderful: The Ripple Effect
    FTC FTC's Complaint Against POM Claims Upheld
    Vitaminwater10 Vitaminwater10
    Pomegranate Blueberry Juice Pomegranate Blueberry Juice
    Coca-Cola Pins Hopes on New Drinks with  Proven Health Benefits Coca-Cola Pins Hopes on New Drinks with Proven Health Benefits
    CAPIToL COMMENTS: Parallel Importation Of Dietary Supplements CAPIToL COMMENTS: Parallel Importation Of Dietary Supplements

    Related Columns

    • Dietary Supplements | Regulations | Research
      Understanding FTC Standards for Claims Substantiation

      Understanding FTC Standards for Claims Substantiation

      Randomized clinical trials aren’t the only source of competent and reliable scientific evidence.
      By Todd Harrison, Venable 06.02.17

    • Dietary Supplements | Digestive Health | Healthcare Trends | Herbs & Botanicals | Quality & Safety | World Markets
      Transforming Health with Nature’s Sunshine

      Transforming Health with Nature’s Sunshine

      With a long history in the supplement market, Nature’s Sunshine remains committed to quality and innovation.
      By Sean Moloughney, Editor 06.02.17

    • Breaking News | Flavors & Colors | Supplier News

      TREHA Trehalose Available As ‘Natural Flavor’

      With improved manufacturing process, TREHA trehalose is now produced from non-GM starch using non-GM enzymes.
      05.25.17


    • Breaking News | Industry & Market News | Testing | Vitamins

      ConsumerLab.com Tests Popular Vitamin D Supplements

      Review includes test results and quality comparisons for 44 products.
      05.22.17

    • Dietary Supplements | Healthcare Trends | Regulations
      Gottlieb Confirmed to Lead FDA

      Gottlieb Confirmed to Lead FDA

      Trade associations offer support for the confirmation.
      05.12.17

    Loading, Please Wait..
    Trending
    • First Day Life Shuts Down Children's Behavioral, Cognitive Health Claims Following Challenge
    • Oregon Files Lawsuit Against GNC
    • Kellogg Splitting into Three Independent Companies
    • Pycnogenol Evidenced To Have Skin Benefits In Dermatology Study
    • CTRL Launches Meal On-The-Go Bars
    Breaking News
    • CoQ10 and Royal Jelly Supplementation May Improve High Intensity Exercise
    • Shiitake Mushroom Extract Appears Helpful in HPV Infections
    • Fi & Hi Europe Returns with Over 20,000 Global Attendees Expected
    • United Plant Savers Launches First Film Festival
    • Azelis Opens Food and Nutrition Lab in Cairo, Egypt
    View Breaking News >
    CURRENT ISSUE

    June 2022

    • Tapping Functional Beverages to Meet Modern Wellness Needs
    • Adaptogens: Where Ancient Remedies Meet Modern Wellness Products
    • New and Evolving Formulation Options Must Be Mindful of Blood Sugar Maintenance
    • Health Products Association - China Executive Director Reflects on Market Dynamics, Challenges
    • Blood Sugar Management: Personalized Testing Drives Home The Need for Early Intervention
    • View More >

    Cookies help us to provide you with an excellent service. By using our website, you declare yourself in agreement with our use of cookies.
    You can obtain detailed information about the use of cookies on our website by clicking on "More information”.

    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms And Conditions
    • Contact Us

    follow us

    Subscribe
    Nutraceuticals World

    Latest Breaking News From Nutraceuticals World

    CoQ10 and Royal Jelly Supplementation May Improve High Intensity Exercise
    Shiitake Mushroom Extract Appears Helpful in HPV Infections
    Fi & Hi Europe Returns with Over 20,000 Global Attendees Expected
    Coatings World

    Latest Breaking News From Coatings World

    H.M. Royal Becomes Exclusive OCSiAl Distributor
    American Colors to Expand Sandusky, Ohio Facility
    Vaughn O’Dea Named Director of Epoxytec
    Medical Product Outsourcing

    Latest Breaking News From Medical Product Outsourcing

    Cepheid, BioGX Partner to Create GeneXpert Monkeypox Test
    Siemens' Varian Gains FDA IDE Nod for FAST-02 Trial
    Acutus Medical Launches AcQCross Line Extension
    Contract Pharma

    Latest Breaking News From Contract Pharma

    Ixaka & Minaris Sign Tech Transfer & GMP Manufacturing Agreement for Cell Therapy Candidate
    Pfizer, BioNTech Adapt COVID Vax Against Omicron
    CoreRx Expands Capabilities
    Beauty Packaging

    Latest Breaking News From Beauty Packaging

    Top 5 Beauty Tech Trends at Perfect Corp.'s Global Forum
    John Frieda Supports the LGBTQIA+ Community
    Athena Club Launches in Canada
    Happi

    Latest Breaking News From Happi

    Fencing Champion Bebe Vio Grandis Named Spokeswoman of L’Oréal Paris
    Past Henkel Exec Christian Chopra Named President of Scotch Porter
    Color Street Celebrates Foster, Adoption Awareness with Limited-Edition Print
    Ink World

    Latest Breaking News From Ink World

    Dr. Tammo Boinowitz to Join Management Board of ALTANA AG
    Flint Offset Packaging Solutions Announces Price Increases for Sheetfed Inks
    Weekly Recap: INX’s VC Fund, Screen Industry and Ball Top This Week’s News
    Label & Narrow Web

    Latest Breaking News From Label & Narrow Web

    Harveer Sahni recognized with Global Achievement Award
    Color-Logic partners with Taktiful 
    ALTANA announces Management Board change
    Nonwovens Industry

    Latest Breaking News From Nonwovens Industry

    Fibertex Personal Care Awarded EcoVadis Awards for Sustainability
    Yanpai Orders Batt Forming Equipment for Needlepunch Line
    Weekly Recap: SWM and Neenah Introduce Mativ Inc., Avgol honored for Biotransformation Technology & More
    Orthopedic Design & Technology

    Latest Breaking News From Orthopedic Design & Technology

    Researchers Discover Novel Patching Material for Bone Defects
    Boston Centerless Opens Second Manufacturing Plant in Indiana
    Researchers Develop Patient-Specific 3D-Printed Smart Metamaterial Implants
    Printed Electronics Now

    Latest Breaking News From Printed Electronics Now

    Identiv-Powered CVS Spoken Rx Wins NFC Forum 2022 Innovation Award
    LG Display Announces Winners of This Year’s OLEDs GO! Competition
    Weekly Recap: eMagin, Applied Materials, and Schott Top This Week’s Stories

    Copyright © 2022 Rodman Media. All rights reserved. Use of this constitutes acceptance of our privacy policy The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Rodman Media.

    AD BLOCKER DETECTED

    Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
    Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.


    FREE SUBSCRIPTION Already a subscriber? Login